For many taxpayers, an increase in income feels like a straightforward positive. Higher earnings should mean more disposable income, even after paying a bit more tax. In practice, the UK tax and benefits system does not always work that way.
There are a number of income thresholds built into the system where allowances and state benefits are reduced or withdrawn altogether once income exceeds a certain level. These losses are often not obvious at the time income increases. Instead of appearing as a new tax charge, they show up as missing allowances or benefits that simply stop.
Understanding how these thresholds work is important, particularly for people whose income fluctuates from year to year or who are close to key limits. Without planning, a relatively modest increase in income can result in a much larger increase in the overall tax burden, or a loss of benefits.
Income thresholds and hidden tax costs
Unlike headline tax rates, these thresholds are rarely discussed in simple terms. They sit in the background of the tax system and can be triggered by events such as bonuses, pay rises, dividends, pension withdrawals or investment income.
What makes them particularly challenging is that the loss of relief or benefit is often sudden. In many cases there is no gradual taper, and even where a taper applies, the effective marginal tax rate can become surprisingly high.
Below are some of the most common examples where rising income can have unintended consequences.
Marriage allowance and moving into higher rate tax
The marriage allowance allows one spouse or civil partner to transfer a portion of their unused personal allowance to the other. This can reduce the recipient’s tax bill, but only where the recipient remains a basic rate taxpayer.
If the recipient’s income increases so that they become a higher rate taxpayer, the marriage allowance is lost entirely for that tax year. There is no partial reduction or taper.
This means that a small increase in taxable income, perhaps due to overtime, a bonus or additional investment income, can result in the full loss of the allowance. Many couples only become aware of this after the tax year has ended, when the tax calculation is prepared and the allowance has already been removed.
Winter fuel allowance and income limits
Recent changes mean that entitlement to the winter fuel allowance is now linked to income. Where an individual’s income exceeds £35,000, the allowance is withdrawn.
This change particularly affects pensioners with mixed sources of income, such as occupational pensions, part-time work or savings income. Because total taxable income can vary from year to year, some individuals may move in and out of entitlement without realising why.
As the allowance is not claimed through the tax return in the same way as many reliefs, the connection between income levels and entitlement is not always clear. The result is often confusion when the payment does not arrive.
Child benefit and higher income households
Child benefit remains one of the most valuable forms of state support for families, but it is also one of the most misunderstood when it comes to income thresholds.
Where one parent has income above £60,000, a high income child benefit charge applies. As income increases above this level, child benefit is gradually clawed back through the tax system. Once income reaches £80,000, the benefit is fully withdrawn.
Importantly, the test applies to the income of the highest earning parent, not to combined household income. This can produce outcomes that feel unfair, particularly where one household has two moderate earners and another has a single higher earner.
The charge is often triggered by one-off income events rather than permanent changes in earnings. Bonuses, dividend payments or the sale of investments can all push income over the threshold for a single tax year, resulting in an unexpected tax bill.
Personal allowance withdrawal above £100,000
One of the most significant thresholds in the UK tax system applies once income exceeds £100,000.
For every £2 of income above this level, £1 of the personal allowance is withdrawn. This continues until the allowance is reduced to nil once income reaches £125,140.
The effect is a high effective tax rate on income within this band. Taxpayers are paying higher rate tax while also losing the benefit of tax-free income at the same time. In practical terms, the marginal tax rate can exceed 60 percent.
This issue commonly affects senior employees, professionals and business owners whose income varies year by year. It is particularly easy to cross the threshold unexpectedly when income comes from multiple sources.
Pension tax relief and higher earners
Pension contributions are often used as a way to manage taxable income, but the interaction between income levels and pension tax relief can be complex.
As income increases, the structure and value of pension relief can change. Higher earners may be affected by the tapered annual allowance, which reduces the amount that can be contributed to pensions with full tax relief.
In some cases, making pension contributions without careful planning can result in reduced relief or even unexpected tax charges. Understanding how income levels affect pension allowances is essential, particularly for those with variable or rising earnings.
Why these issues are often missed
What these examples have in common is that the impact is rarely obvious from payslips alone. Many allowances and benefits are assessed separately from day-to-day payroll, and the consequences may only become clear when a tax return is prepared or when a benefit is withdrawn.
It is also common for individuals to be affected by more than one threshold at the same time. A single increase in income can trigger multiple losses, compounding the overall effect.
Because the rules are complex and spread across different parts of the tax and benefits system, the true cost of higher income is often underestimated.
The value of forward planning
The good news is that many of these outcomes can be managed with advance planning. Timing of income, pension contributions, charitable donations and the way income is shared between spouses can all influence whether key thresholds are crossed.
Regular reviews are particularly important for anyone approaching one of the income limits discussed above or whose income varies from year to year. Understanding where income is likely to fall before the end of the tax year creates opportunities to make informed decisions while there is still time to act.
If you are unsure how close your income is to any of these thresholds, or if a recent increase in earnings may have unintended consequences, professional advice can help you understand your position and avoid unnecessary loss of allowances and benefits.
If you feel this alert could help a business colleague or family member, please feel free to share it with them.
